If a contractor's work or conduct goes wrong, the state agency to go to is the Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses (DOPL). DOPL houses the Idaho Contractors Board, which registers general contractors, and the boards that license electricians, plumbers, HVAC installers and public works contractors. This page explains how a complaint works, what the board can do, and where its power stops.

Start with the contractor

The Idaho Attorney General's Consumer Protection Manual advises talking to the contractor's manager or owner first, then following up with a certified letter confirming the details of the conversation. Keep records of every call and every letter. If that doesn't solve it, the manual points you to DOPL.

Your letter should say what's wrong, what you want done, and by when. Attach photos. It becomes evidence for the complaint.

Who to file with

Who did the work Board Where to file
General contractor, remodeler, roofer and other registered contractors Idaho Contractors Board dopl.idaho.gov/con, "File a Complaint Against a Registration"
Electrical contractor or electrician Idaho Electrical Board dopl.idaho.gov/ele, "File a Complaint Against a Licensee"
Plumbing contractor or plumber State Plumbing Board dopl.idaho.gov/plb, "File a Complaint Against a Licensee"
HVAC contractor or installer HVAC Board dopl.idaho.gov/hvac, "File a Complaint Against a Licensee"
Manufactured home installer and building matters Building Code Board dopl.idaho.gov/bld, "File a Complaint Against a Licensee"

On the Contractors Board page, the complaint button opens DOPL Online Services. For questions, DOPL's contractor board lists BCRE-Licensing@dopl.idaho.gov and (208) 334-3233.

What to put in the complaint

Under Idaho Code 67-2616(9), any person may file a complaint with the board that issued the license or registration. The complaint must specify the charges in enough detail to tell the contractor what misconduct is alleged.

Include:

  • the contractor's name and registration or license number (from the contract, permit or DOPL's public search)
  • the property address and dates of work
  • the contract, change orders, invoices and payment records
  • photos of the problem
  • your letters to the contractor and any replies
  • the building permit number and inspection results, if any
  • the 45-525 disclosure you received, or a note that you never got one

Tie each fact to a rule if you can. Common grounds for contractor discipline under 54-5215(2) include:

  • violating the registration chapter, including failing to keep insurance current
  • violating the Idaho Consumer Protection Act, including fraudulent misrepresentations to consumers
  • fraud or misrepresentation in getting a registration or a building permit
  • violating laws relevant to contracting in a way that makes the contractor a threat to public safety
  • any other conduct that amounts to dishonest or dishonorable dealings
  • interfering with an investigation by misrepresentation, threats or harassment

DOPL's Contractors Board FAQ calls out three of these as the most pertinent: violating the Act (such as failing to carry insurance), violating the Consumer Protection Act (such as misleading statements), and dishonest or dishonorable dealings.

What happens next

  1. Notice and response. The board notifies the registrant or licensee of the complaint and requests a response. If the board decides it lacks jurisdiction, it must tell you (67-2616(9)).
  2. Investigation. On a written complaint from someone who says they were injured or defrauded, the Contractors Board shall investigate the facts alleged (54-5215(1)). Boards can issue subpoenas, take depositions and require records (67-2616(1)).
  3. Formal action or informal resolution. If the facts are enough, the board may file an administrative complaint (54-5215(1)). Formal discipline follows contested case procedures under Chapter 52 of Title 67 (67-2616(5)). A board may instead settle by negotiation, stipulation or consent order, or accept a surrender of the license (67-2616(6)).

Each board keeps a file on every complaint, recording who was contacted, findings at each step, and the legal reason if the complaint is dismissed (67-2616(9)). That file is confidential (67-2615(1)). If the matter is settled informally, it may stay confidential, but you can request a status report as the original complainant (67-2616(6)).

What DOPL can do

Action Source
Informal letter of reprimand or formal reprimand 54-5215(2)
Suspend or revoke the registration 54-5215(2)
Civil penalty up to $1,000 for a registered contractor 54-5215(2)
Refuse to renew, or restrict the license for a set period 67-2616(3)(a), (d)
Require education or training 67-2616(3)(e)
Require restitution for losses or reimbursement of damages caused by a violation 67-2616(3)(g)
Assess investigation costs and attorney's fees 67-2616(3)(i)
Ask a district court to enjoin continuing violations 54-5215(1), 67-2616(2)
Refer a criminal violation to the county prosecutor 67-2616(10)

The board keeps jurisdiction over a registration even after it lapses for nonrenewal (67-2616(8)). A contractor can't escape a complaint by letting the registration expire.

What DOPL can't do

  • It isn't a court. The process is discipline of a license or registration. It doesn't produce a court judgment you can collect against the contractor's bank account.
  • Its penalties have limits. Discipline must stay consistent with each board's own practice act (67-2616(4)). For registered contractors, the civil penalty cap is $1,000 (54-5215(2)).
  • Restitution isn't automatic. It's one possible order, not a promised outcome.
  • Court deadlines are separate. A lien's six-month enforcement period (Idaho Code 45-510) and the two-year limit for a private Consumer Protection Act suit (48-619) are set by their own sections, which say nothing about DOPL complaints. If one of those dates is close, talk to a lawyer rather than wait on DOPL.

Other routes for getting money back

  • Small claims. Idaho magistrate courts have small claims departments for money claims up to $15,000. Small claims can't award punitive damages or damages for pain and suffering (Idaho Code 1-2301).
  • Consumer Protection Act suit. If you lost money from a deceptive practice, you may sue for actual damages or $1,000, whichever is greater, with attorney's fees if you win (48-608). See the Idaho Consumer Protection Act and contractors.
  • Attorney General. The AG's Consumer Protection Division takes consumer complaints at (208) 334-2424 or toll-free 1-800-432-3545.
  • Insurance. If the contractor damaged your property, ask for the insurer's details. The board releases them to people stating they have a claim (54-5210(1)(e)). See contractor insurance requirements.

If the contractor wasn't registered

Report it. The Contractors Board may investigate anyone believed to have acted as a contractor without registering and may seek injunctive relief (54-5215(1)). An unregistered contractor also can't lien your home or sue you to collect. See penalties for unregistered contractors.

Before your next project, use the hiring checklist and the Idaho licensing guide.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I file a complaint against an Idaho contractor?

Use the 'File a Complaint Against a Registration' button on DOPL's Contractors Board page, which opens DOPL Online Services. Electrical, plumbing, HVAC and building boards have their own 'File a Complaint Against a Licensee' links. Under Idaho Code 67-2616(9), the complaint must describe the charges in enough detail to show the contractor what misconduct is alleged.

Can DOPL make my contractor pay me back?

A DOPL board can include restitution for losses or reimbursement for damages caused by a violation among its disciplinary orders (Idaho Code 67-2616(3)(g)). Discipline must stay within the contractor's practice act, and a complaint isn't a lawsuit. If you need a money judgment, small claims court handles claims up to $15,000 (Idaho Code 1-2301).

Can I see DOPL's complaint file on my case?

Complaint and investigation records are DOPL's property and exempt from disclosure under the public records act (Idaho Code 67-2615(1)). If a matter is settled informally, you can request a status report as the original complainant (67-2616(6)). Formal actions against registered contractors show in DOPL's public search.

Can I complain about someone who isn't registered at all?

Yes. The Idaho Contractors Board may investigate anyone believed to have acted as a contractor without registering, and may seek an injunction stopping them from construction (Idaho Code 54-5215(1)). Boards may also refer criminal violations to the county prosecutor (67-2616(10)).